Inherited Morality
How Evolution (Not God) Built Your Conscience
You’re reading my free posts, where I dissect religious dogma and challenge faith-based narratives with facts and critical thinking.
Please consider becoming a paid subscriber for just $6.66/month (yes, intentional). Your support helps fund my work giving me more time to challenge harmful ideas, champion equal rights, and take on Christian nationalism.
Reasoned Reality’s Substack is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.
Remember, together, we can make all the difference.
Why Kindness, Fairness, and Altruism are Biological Imperatives
The most common argument for the existence of a divine creator is the “Moral Argument.” It suggests that without a celestial lawgiver, humans would have no reason to be good. However, when we consult the fields of evolutionary biology and anthropology, we find that morality is not a top-down gift from the heavens. It is a bottom-up survival strategy. We are “good” because we are a social species whose survival depended entirely on our ability to cooperate.
The Primate Precedent: Fairness Before Faith
If morality were purely a religious construct, we would expect to see “moral” behavior only in humans who have been exposed to divine revelation. Yet, when we look at our closest living relatives—chimpanzees and bonobos—we see the foundations of what we call “ethics.”
In the book The Bonobo and the Atheist, Frans de Waal describes experiments demonstrating that monkeys have a profound sense of Fairness. When two capuchin monkeys were given a task and one was rewarded with a cucumber while the other received a grape for the same work, the monkey receiving the cucumber immediately recognized the inequality and protested. This “sense of fairness” evolved long before the first prayer was ever uttered. It is a biological prerequisite for living in a group.
Game Theory and the Logic of Altruism
Evolutionary biologists use Game Theory to explain Reciprocal Altruism. If you share your food today, you are more likely to be helped when you are starving tomorrow. Over millions of years, the genes of those who cooperated were passed on, while the genes of “cheaters” were marginalized.
Our “conscience” is the neurological reward system—the release of oxytocin and dopamine—for behaviors that keep the tribe alive. We aren’t being “holy”; we are being reinforced by our own chemistry to ensure the survival of our species. Empathy is a function of “Mirror Neurons” in the brain that allow us to feel what another is feeling, a trait found across the animal kingdom in mammals that care for their young.
The Danger of “Divine” Morality
The problem with basing morality on a “Divine Lawgiver” is that it makes ethics brittle. If you believe your moral code was written in stone 3,000 years ago, you cannot easily adapt to new information. This is why many religious institutions historically defended slavery and the subjugation of women—they were following a “fixed” moral code that reflected the prejudices of Bronze Age men.
In the study The Construction of Moral Identity in the Hebrew Bible, Dan McClellan shows how different biblical authors had vastly different moralities based on their cultural contexts. When we realize that morality is an Evolved Skill, we gain the freedom to improve it. We can apply reason to identify which behaviors reduce suffering. We don’t need a commandment to know that causing unnecessary harm is “bad”—we have 4 billion years of biological evolution telling us so.
Secular Flourishing: Being Good Without a Ghost
The data proves that religion is not a requirement for a moral society. As noted in the book Society without God by Phil Zuckerman, many of the most secular countries on Earth have the lowest crime rates and highest levels of social trust. We are “good” because we want to live in a world where goodness is the norm.
Your sense of right and wrong is a legacy left to you by millions of ancestors who survived because they learned to trust, share, and protect one another. Morality is the shared language of a species that knows we are stronger together than we are apart.
References:
de Waal, Frans. (2013). The Bonobo and the Atheist: In Search of Humanism Among the Primates. W. W. Norton & Company.
Axelrod, Robert. (1984). The Evolution of Cooperation. Basic Books.
McClellan, Daniel O. (2023). The Construction of Moral Identity in the Hebrew Bible.
Zuckerman, Phil. (2008). Society without God: What the Least Religious Nations Can Tell Us About Contentment. NYU Press.
One of the best ways you can help the Reasoned Reality Project is by sharing our posts, following us on Instagram and subscribing to our podcast. And if you haven’t subscribed to the Substack, its free unless you wish to support us through a paid subscription. Remember, you might be the only voice of reason today. Don’t be afraid to use it.
References: